When an agency says, “we need more outbound”, my first instinct is not to start building lists.
I would first ask whether they have exhausted the opportunities already sitting much closer to them: old clients, previous opportunities, deals that were lost, leads that went quiet and people already in the CRM who were interested at some point but were never properly nurtured.
Outbound is one of the harder ways to generate new business because you are starting without an existing relationship. It is proactive, which makes it important, but that does not mean it should automatically be the first place you look.
Start where you already have the right to win
The first question is not simply, “who could buy this?” It is, “where do we have the best chance of being credible?”
If an agency has already worked successfully with ecommerce brands, manufacturers or financial services businesses, I would normally start there.
Existing experience gives you proof. You have relevant logos, case studies, testimonials and examples of the problems you have already solved. That matters because every piece of proof reduces perceived risk for the prospect.
Your ICP probably needs another layer
One mistake I see is defining an ICP too broadly.
“Retail businesses” is not really an ICP. Neither is “companies with 50 to 500 employees”.
I tend to think about adding several layers. For example: sector, company size, then a signal such as headcount growth, funding, hiring, technology change or geographical expansion.
Think about outbound like an investment portfolio
I do not think there is one correct level of targeting.
If you make every campaign incredibly specific, you can spend all week building highly personalised activity for twenty companies and get nothing back. At the opposite extreme, you can send thousands of generic messages and burn through a market very quickly.
I prefer thinking about outbound as a portfolio: a small number of high-value accounts receiving considered multi-channel outreach, narrower campaigns built around a specific sector or problem, and broader campaigns where the proposition has relevance across a larger market.
Authenticity beats over-engineered personalisation
There is a lot of advice about personalising outbound. Sometimes that helps. But I have not consistently seen dramatically better reply rates just because somebody's company name appears in the message.
What seems to matter more is whether the message feels like it came from an actual person.
I generally prefer messages that feel closer to something you might genuinely send somebody on WhatsApp: clear, short, human and easy to respond to.
LinkedIn, email and phone do different jobs
I would almost always use a multi-channel approach, but I would not necessarily use every channel equally for every prospect.
My rough view is that LinkedIn is very good for generating replies, phone is often the strongest channel for creating genuine opportunity, and email becomes particularly useful once a conversation has started and you want to formalise or progress it.
You probably need more volume than you think
Outbound usually requires a meaningful level of activity. That does not mean sending as many messages as physically possible. It means recognising that even good outbound has relatively low conversion rates compared with warmer sources of business.
When a campaign is not working, simplify before you complicate
One of the first things I look at is reply rate. If it is lower than expected, I will often simplify the message: less polish, less jargon, less explanation and a smaller ask.
A positive reply is where the real work starts
Getting the response is not the end goal. As soon as somebody replies positively, I want that conversation captured, flagged, recorded in the CRM and responded to quickly.
Build a catalogue of reasons to get back in touch
An audit. An event. A coffee. An interview. A research project. A useful introduction. A conversation with a specialist.
Think of it almost like looking through a menu. When you reconnect with someone, you should not always have to send another blog post or white paper.
Bad outbound can burn a market
You only get so many opportunities to make a first impression. If a prospect receives a sequence that clearly does not understand who they are, they may not simply ignore that campaign. They may remember the company negatively.
Outbound does not deserve its bad reputation
Outbound itself is not the problem. Poor outbound is.
Done properly, it is simply another route to market alongside inbound, referrals, partnerships and events.
So what?
If I inherited an agency's outbound tomorrow, I would start with three things: who they are contacting, what they are saying, and how the campaign is structured.
And before doing any of that, I would still check the CRM for the opportunities the business has already earned and forgotten about.
The principle I would keep coming back to is this: Treat new business like a portfolio.
Spread the risk, learn what works and put more effort behind the approaches that consistently create worthwhile conversations.